Making the invisible visible

Which are the techniques of self-censorship used by erotic magazines to deal with Instagram policy?

Erotic Independent Fashion Photography The percentage refers to the quantity of self - censored photos on the Instagram profiles of the magazines. It is based on the last posts of the magazine, for a maximum of 200. Self - censorship techniques Post history 1 photo Pixel Sketch Emoji Objects Symbols Text Clone stamp Geometric shapes Mixed techniques Other Latest posts Older posts Hustler69% Leste4% Pinups8,5% Ossì Fanzine37,5% Ladybeard1,5% Polyester4% Cavie Project10,4% Phile2% Odiseo2,5% Playboy Colombia12,5% Self Control9% Playboy Mexico11,5% Another Filthy Magazine7,5% Playboy Germany9,5% Penthouse Australia8,5% Normal67% Playboy Sweden2,5% Nakd21,9% Penthouse11,5% Playboy Portugal11% Playboy Switzerland15,5% Lions7,5% Lui29,5% Playboy27% Playboy Italy0,5% S23,5% Baroness8,5% Hot Sauce3,7% Math1,5% Suspira1% Cold Cuts2,6% Pop1% Lyra0,5% Sabat0,5% C-Heads9,5% Nasty3,5% Le Dauphin2,5% Self Service2,5% Baron12% True Photo Journal3,5%

Instagram is useful to increase brand awareness, but when the brands are magazines related to sensitive or erotic topics, they have to face its policy. So, they have tried different techniques of self-censorship to ensure their presence on Instagram. The research has produced a database of self-censored posts of these magazines, that allows analyzing the visual languages and their evolution.

Main Findings

In most of the analyzed cases, magazines prefer a specific language of self-censorship; for instance, “Hustler” mainly uses symbols, and “Baron” applies pixels.


Self-censorship is sometimes made of mixed techniques; for example, “Leste” used both sketch and text to cover a woman’s breasts in one post.

example of secondary visualization


An unusual technique of self-censorship involves objects. This is the case of “Self Service” and “Ossì Fanzine” that publish posts in which physical objects overlap printed materials to cover body parts.

example of secondary visualization


Over time, “Playboy” has changed its style of self-censorship, going from sketch to pixels without using other types of language; on the contrary, “S” had a deep change of style, but with some intermediate variations.

example of secondary visualization

Protocol

example of protocol

Data sources

Date of retrieval