Digital dating: faking oneself & stolen profiles

How much criticism relates to chatbots and fake profiles in user app reviews?

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 Badoo Bumble Clover Coffee Meets Bagel eharmony happn HER Hinge Match muzmatch OkCupid Plenty of Fish Ship Tinder Zoosk scam scams scammer scammers scamming bot bots spam spammers fake accounts fake profile fake profiles fake user fake users fakes stolen KEYWORDS 5 4 3 2 1 SCORE 1 ORDER 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 HITS APP STORE 0 5 10 15 20 Clover Hinge Badoo Bumble happn Heyyo Dating Around OkCupid Plenty of Fish Tagged Tinder Waplog Free Dating App & Flirt Chat Mingle2 Hily HITS scam scams scammer scammers scamming bot bots spam fake accounts fake profile fake profiles fake user fakes KEYWORDS 5 4 3 2 1 SCORE 1 ORDER 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 GOOGLE PLAY

The most popular dating apps seem to have a bot problem. Users manifest their dissatisfaction towards fake profiles and spam through the review section on the App Store and the Google Play Store. We picked the 15 most popular apps on both platforms and analyzed users’ opinions based on how often they mention certain keywords and which scores they provided.

Main Findings

Plenty of Fish is the most problematic app in terms of bots, scams and fake profiles. As a consequence of that, the percentage of very bad reviews is much higher than most other apps: 65% of App Store reviews and 32% of Google Play Store reviews are 1-star.
The apps with the worst average scores are eharmony (average 1.45 on the App Store) and Heyyo (average 1.8 on the Google Play Store).

The most popular app on the App Store appears to be Badoo. Aside from the small number of occurrences of keywords, 91% of the reviews are positive (4-/5-stars) with an average score of 4.59.
In the same position on Google Play, Dating Around’s reviews are 99% positive (5-stars) with a sky‑high average of 4.96.

Heyyo on the Google Play Store is an oddity. As far as number of reviews is concerned, it was only reviewed 5 times (as of November 7, 2019); four out of these five are 1-star. Despite this, it is the twelfth app to appear in the search results, indicating relatively high interest towards it.

It is worth noting that on the App Store, through Apple ID, users are not required to use their first and last names to sign their reviews; they can use pseudonyms or even fake names, which may allow them to feel that they can be “harsher” with their reviews.
On the other hand, the Google Play Store’s account system requires real first and last names (from a Google Account), so this may discourage some people from being too “blunt”.

Protocol

Protocol 05

Data sources

Date of retrieval